Engineering Radio

This post is about a Large Loop On Ground (LLOG) receive antenna.

I have, for some time, been lamenting the demise of my K9AY antenna last year. While I don’t spend a lot of time Shortwave Listening these days, it is sometimes a nice diversion on a rainy day.

I have been reading about LOG (Loop on Ground) broadband receive antennas for a few years and the concept sounds interesting. Loop antennas in general, tend to reject RF noise better than dipole or vertical ground plane type receivers.

The idea is the loop antennas are more H field (magnetic) than E field (electrical) receivers. Most unintentional RF noise generators create noise in the E field.

Additionally, close proximity to the ground further lowers E field noise due to capacitive coupling with the ground. The ground acting as a sink for the E field noise. Loops also tend to have better rejection of chaotic Near Field energy. Thus the combination of those three things will create slightly lower signal with much better signal to noise ratios over traditional up in the air antennas.

The downside is that it cannot be used for transmitting. The capacitive coupling noted above will quickly dissipate all of the transmitted RF into ground as heat.

The LOG antenna that most amateur radio operators use is either or close to the antenna outlined by Matt, KK4JY: The Loop on Ground Antenna

That is all well and good, but I want something larger to go down through the entire Medium Frequency band in into Low Frequency range. The main reason is I want to start fooling around with the 2200 and 630 meter amateur radio bands. Also, wanting a good low noise AM broadcast receive antenna. With that in mind, I began taking inventory of available real estate and parts.

As for real estate; I own a patch of woods behind my house that is approximately 200 x 200 feet. Good enough for a fairly large square loop. The good thing about particular plot of land is it is far away from the neighbors, the utility lines and other sources of electrical noise.

As for the available parts; it turns out I had almost everything needed. The only thing I needed to purchase is a water tight outdoor enclosure for the matching transformer, from Amazon for $9.00.

Here is a list of items used:

The wire is copper THHN 14 gauge. If buying new, this is the single largest expense. I soldered and heat shrunk several lengths from left overs on spools. This antenna is going to be in the shade, so I don’t have to worry too much about UV degradation of the insulation. If that happens, I can find some more insulated wire.

The big bonus is the Cablewave FCC38-50J phase stabilized cable, most of which is buried out to my old K9AY antenna, I simply extended it about 50 feet. Having the line already buried to much of the manual labor out of the project. The buried section of line acts as an RF choke, fully eliminating any electrical noise coming from my house at the antenna side of the line.

I did have to go around and clear away some brush and dead trees along where the antenna wire was laid on the ground. I wanted to make sure that the wire was directly on or within an inch or two of the ground.

The transformer took about 20 minutes to construct. It consists of six windings on the antenna side and two windings on the transmission line side. I used a type 73 core because I am more interested in the medium frequency range. It seems to work well up to about 15 MHz. The transformer is for galvanic isolation, keeping the loop current balanced and separated from the transmission line. The shield is not grounded at the antenna side, but is grounded where it comes into the house. On the transformer enclosure, I used a salvaged N connector to match what I had for the transmission line. Any low loss cable, including RG-6 or RG-11 will work very well.

After a few hours of low intensity work, I had everything together. I connected the antenna to my trusty Kenwood R-2000 receiver and tuned to the nearest Class C AM on 1,490 KHz. Wow! What a difference! This little 1 KW high band station 18.6 miles (30 km) away barely came in before, especially when the ground is dried out. The relative signal strength meter on the receiver shows an S9+5. I am located on the edge of the predicted 0.5 mV/M contour while the spectrum analyzer shows a -65 dB signal, which is netting a 44 dB SNR, which is very good. All of this is after a Mini Circuits ZSC-4-2 power divider, which has an insertion loss of -6 dB per port.

One of the reasons for the “decline of AM;” overcrowding. This was taken during the daytime, when there was no skywave propagation. Barely an open frequency.

With the spectrum analyzer and made a few interesting discoveries. First, the noise floor in the Medium Frequency range goes from about -100 to -110 depending on the frequency. The noise floor on High Frequency is -112 or lower across the entire band. I clearly get all of the NYC AM stations as well as most of the stations in and around Albany. Before sunrise, I tuned around the 630 (472 to 479 KHz) meter band and heard a few stations sending CW (W4TS @ 164 miles (264 KM), K2ORS @ 157.2 miles (253 KM)). A few overnights of WSPR monitoring on 475.6 KHz netted 194 spots from 11 different stations. The furthest was 822 miles (1,322 KM) away in central Illinois. All of these stations are transmitting 5 watts EIRP or less.

This antenna works well to about 15 MHz, where the signals start to drop off because of the transformer material that I used.

Using the Network Analyzer, I found the resonance is 2.865 MHz with a -36 dB return loss. This makes sense, as the wire laying on the ground will have a lower velocity factor due to the capacitive coupling with the earth. In this case the VF of the antenna is 73% when the soil is dry. The velocity factor should go down when the ground gets wet, or covered with snow.

It might be interesting to do some ground conductivity measurements…